When mockumentary gets Italian: Il ritorno di Cagliostro along the lines of Forgotten Silver

  • Emanuele Broccio Università Paris Nanterre
Keywords: mockumentary, intertextuality, spectator, biopic, reality

Abstract

Playing on a fusion between the aesthetic strategies of the documentary as a genre and the discursive features of the fiction, Il ritorno di Cagliostro (Ciprì and Maresco: 2003) should be classified within that filmic category called mockumentary. The following essay will analyse first how the techniques used put the spectator in a continuous oscillation between the feeling of witnessing real-life situations and the suspicion of fiction. The alternation of the two systems, around which the film is structured, thus dynamically characterizes the communication pact. Secondly, we will examine Forgotten Silver by Peter Jackson which is the foreign model that acts behind Ciprì and Maresco’s formal choices, highlighting how the most significant difference can be traced on a thematic level. Subject, setting and plot, they all contribute – often in the forms of the grotesque – to a lucid and radical critique of Italian political and religious institutions. Finally, the study thus conducted will allow us to recognise Il ritorno di Cagliostro as an attempt to respond to today's need of the cinema for a return to reality.

Author Biography

Emanuele Broccio, Università Paris Nanterre

Emanuele Broccio is a researcher with a specific interest in Italian Contemporary Literature,Comparative Literatureand Cinema, currently teaching at the University of France. He is author of two monographs: Tra amore e Resistenza. La drammaturgia di Beppe Fenoglio (Il Mulino, 2017) and Dal corpo assediato alle macerie della memoria. La poesia di Jolanda Insana (Carabba, 2018). Broccio has worked with some well-known journals, such as “Narrativa” and “ChroniquesItaliennes”, publishing several essays. He is an associate member of the research center for Italian studies CRIX (Centre de Recherches Italiennes) at the University of Paris Nanterre. In March 2017 he obtained the French national scientific qualification of Italian Studiesat the level of Associate Professor (Maître de conference).

References

Antonello, Pierpaolo, Mussgnug, Florian, Postmodern Impegno. Ethics and Commitment in contemporayItalian Culture, Oxford, Peter Lang, 2009.

Bordoni, Andrea - Marino, Matteo, Peter Jackson, Milano, Il Castoro, 2001.

Buttitta, Ignazio, " Lu trenu di lu suli ", Il treno del sole / storie, canti di protesta, canzoni in dialetto siciliano con traduzioni a fronte. Eds. Roberto Leydi – Leonardo Sciascia, Milano, Edizioni Avanti, 1963.

Casetti, Francesco, L’occhio del Novecento. Cinema, esperienza, modernità, Milano, Bompiani, 2005.

Canova, Gianni, “Potere”, Lessico del cinema italiano II, Ed. Roberto De Gaetano, Milano-Udine, Mimesis, 2015: 429-506.

Chapple, Geoff, “Gone, not Forgotten”, Listener, 2901 (1995).

Colombo Fausto, “Leonard, o del falso: nota su Zelig di Woody Allen”, Comunicazioni sociali, 6.1, (1984): 49-58.

Conrich, Ian - Smith, Roy, “Fool's gold: New Zealand's 'Forgotten silver', Myth and National Identity”, Studies in New Zealand cinema, Ed. Ian Conrich, London, Kakapo Books, 2009: 137-150.

Ceruso, Vincenzo, La chiesa e la mafia: viaggio dentro le sagrestie di Cosa nostra, Roma, Newton Compton, 2010.

De Caro, Mario, Ferraris, Maurizio (ed.), Bentornata realtà. Il nuovo realismo in discussione, Torino, Einaudi, 2012.

Donnarumma, Raffaele - Policastro, Gilda - Taviani, Giovanna, “Ritorno alla realtà? Narrativa e cinema alla fine del postmoderno”, Allegoria, 57 (2008).

Dottorini, Daniele, La passione del reale. Il documentario o la creazione del mondo, Milano, Mimesis, 2018.

Formenti, Cristina, Il mockumentary. La fiction si maschera da documentario, Milano, Mimesis, 2013.

Fanchi, Mariagrazia, Spettatore, Milano, Il Castoro, 2005.

Genette, Gerard, Palinsesti(1982), Torino, Einaudi, 1997.

Mayne, Judith, Cinema and Spectatorship, New York, Routledge, 1993.

Odin, Roger, De la fiction, Bruxelles, De Boeck Université, 2000.

Privitera, Daniela, “Nel nome del Padre e del... padrino. Chiesa e mafia nella letteratura siciliana”, Italica, 92.1, 2015: 33-42.

Roscoe, Jane, “Mocumentary”, Encyclopedia of the Documentary, New York, Routledge, 2006.

Roscoe, Jane – Hight, Craig, “Forgotten Silver: A New Zealand Television Hoax and its Audience”, F is for Phony. Fake Documentary and Truth’s Undoing, Ed. Alexandra Juhasz, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2006: 171-186.

Sadashige, Jacqui, “Forgotten Silver by Sue Rogers, Peter Jackson, Costa Botes”, The American Historical Review, 1997: 938-939.

Sales, Isaia, I preti e i mafiosi. Storia dei rapporti tra mafie e Chiesa cattolica, Catanzaro, Rubbettino, 2014.

Stam, Robert, Film Theory: an Introduction, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 2000.

St. Ours, Kathryn, “The Time-Image from Pasolini to Ciprì and Maresco”, Romance Notes, 51.2, 2011: 199-208.

Venturelli, Renato, “Film biografico”, Encicolpedia del cinema, Roma, Istituto dell’Enciclopedia Italiana, 2003, I.

Published
2019-11-30
How to Cite
Broccio, E. (2019). When mockumentary gets Italian: <i>Il ritorno di Cagliostro</i> along the lines of <i>Forgotten Silver</i&gt;. Between, 9(18). https://doi.org/10.13125/2039-6597/3751