Sanctuaries in the Sardinian Bronze Age and Early Iron Age landscape (1200-700 BC): Network analysis and GIS approach
Abstract
This paper aims to investigate the role of the sanctuaries in regards to the settlement-pattern, control of metal resources and mobility of those resources during the Final Bronze Age (1200-900 BC) and Early Iron Age (900-700 BC) in Nuragic Sardinia.
The rise of Nuragic sanctuaries relates as a response to a profound societal and economic crisis that invests the Nuragic civilization around 1200 BC. Defined as ‘territorial compounds’ and generally associated with the cult of water, the rise of these new types of settlements corresponds also to a period of increasing metal production, internal and external metal trade.
However, their role in a model that investigates the control, exchange and the internal mobility of metal resources have never been conceptualized or tested.
In this paper, I argue that the rise of the sanctuaries acted as symbolic, territorial and economic nodes within and between Nuragic settlements and natural resources.
The study takes advantage of spatial analysis applied with two different methods: Terrain analyses through GIS and Network Analysis. Cost Surface Analysis and Least Cost Path to investigate mobility patterns between sanctuaries, settlements and metal resources. The results will be used in the Network Analysis to understand the role of sanctuaries in connection to the exchange of metal resources among settlements.
Downloads
References
AITKEN 1977: Aitken, R. 1977. Wilderness areas in Scotland. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis. University of Aberdeen.
ANGIUS ET AL. 2012: Angius V., Antona A., Cadeddu F., Puggioni S. 2012, Territorio e popolamento nella Gallura Nuragica. Un’ipotesi metodologica, in Atti della XLIV Riunione Scientifica, La preistoria e la protostoria della Sardegna, Volume III-Comunicazioni, Firenze, pp.1215-1221
BEGEMANN ET AL. 2001: Begemann F., Schmitt-Strecker S., Pernicka E., Lo Schiavo F., 2001, Chemical composition and Lead Isotopy of copper and bronze in Nuragic Sardinia, in «European Journal of Archaeology» (4) 1, pp. 43-85
BELL AND LOCK 2000: Bell T., Lock G., 2000, Topographic and cultural influences on walking the Ridgeway in later prehistoric times, in G. Lock (ed.), Beyond the Map: Archaeology and Spatial Technologies, pp. 85-100, Amsterdam: IOS Press
BERNARDINI 2017: Bernardini P. 2017, Santuari, culti e ideologia del potere nella Sardegna Nuragica della Prima Età del Ferro, in Moravetti A., Melis P.,Foddai L., Alba E. (eds.) La Sardegna Nuragica, Storia e Monumenti- Corpora delle Antichità della Sardegna, Carlo Delfino Editore, pp. 212-222.
BLAKE 2001: Blake E., 2001, Constructing a Nuragic locale: the spatial relationship between tombs and towers in Bronze Age Sardinia, in «American Journal of Archaeology» (105) 2: 145
BLAKE 2008: Blake E. 2008, Situating Sardinia’s giant’s tombs in their spatial, social and temporal contexts, in Silverman H. and Small D.B. (eds), The Space and Place of Death, Archeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association 11(1):119 - 127
BRUGHMANS 2010: Brughmans, T. (2010), Connecting the dots: Towards Archaeological Network Analysis. «Oxford Journal of Archaeology», 29: 277-303. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0092.2010.00349.x
CABRAS 2018: Cabras M., 2018, Patrones de asientamento de la Edad del Bronce en el Monte Arci y Alta Marmilla, Cerdeña centro-occidental, Tesi doctoral, Universidad de Granada (Spain), 2018
CÁMARA SERRANO AND SPANEDDA 2014: Cámara Serrano, J.A.; Spanedda, L. 2014, L’organizzazione sociale nuragica: Note e ipotesi. In Moravetti, A.; Alba, E.; Foddai, L. (eds), La Sardegna Nuragica: Storia e materiali. Roma: Regione Autonoma della Sardegna, pp. 151-159
CAMPUS ET AL. 2010: Campus F., Leonelli V., Lo Schiavo F., 2010, La transizione culturale dall’età del bronzo all’età del ferro nella Sardegna nuragica in relazione all’Italia tirrenica, in «Bollettino di Archeologia online», International Congress of Classical Archaeology- Meetings between cultures in the Ancient Mediterrenean, Roma 2008, pp. 62-76
CAMPUS 2015: Campus F., 2015, Reperti ceramici e bronzei dalle campagne di scavo degli anni ’60. Inquadramento tipologico e cronologico e proposta per una cronologia del complesso cultuale di di Serri, in Canu N., Cicilloni R. (eds), Il Santuario di Santa Vittoria di Serri, tra archeologia del passato e archeologia del futuro, Ed. Quasar, (Estratto), pp. 1-27
CHAPMAN 2006: Chapman H. 2006, Landscape Archaeology and GIS, Tempus Publishing Limited
CICILLONI AND CABRAS 2014: Cicilloni R., Cabras M. 2014, Aspetti insediativi nel versante orientale del Monte Arci (Oristano-Sardegna) tra il Bronzo Medio e la Prima Età del Ferro, in «Quaderni» 25/2014, pp. 81- 107.
CICILLONI ET AL. 2014: Cicilloni R., Ragucci G., Cabras M., Mossa A., 2014 New Approaches in Landscape Analysis of the Bronze Age in Central-Western Sardinia: the Area of Mogoro (Oristano- Italy), in LAC 2014 Proceedings , Third International Landscape Archaeology Conference, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, pp. 1-12, http://lac2014proceedings.nl/article/view/56.
CINCOTTI ET AL. 2003: Cincotti A., Massidda L., Sanna U., 2003, Chemical and isotope characterization of lead finds at the Santa Barbara nuraghe (Bauladu, Sardinia), in «Journal of Cultural Heritage» 4 (2003), pp. 263-268
DAVID AND THOMAS 2008: David B., Thomas J. 2008, Handbook of Landscape Archaeology, Routledge Taylor&Francis Editors, London.
DE MONTIS AND CASCHILI 2012: De Montis A., Caschili S. 2012, Nuraghes and landscape planning: Coupling viewshed with complex network analysis, in «Landscape and Urban Planning», Vol. 105 (3), pp. 315-324.
DEPALMAS 1998: Depalmas A. 1998, Organizzazione ed assetto territoriale nella regione di Sedilo durante i tempi preistorici, in «Antichità sarde», Vol. 3.3, Uniss Research, pp. 33-76.
DEPALMAS 2003: Depalmas A. 2003, Scelte insediative e aspetti del popolamento nella Sardegna in età nuragica, in «Historia Antiqua» vol. 11, Uniss, Pula, pp.13-21.
DEPALMAS 2014: Depalmas A., 2014, Il paesaggio del sacro nella Sardegna nuragica. Architetture celebrative e spazi cerimoniali nei luoghi di culto e nei santuari, in Negroni Catacchio (ed.), Paesaggi cerimoniali. Ricerche e scavi, Atti dell’Undicesimo Incontro di Studi, Valentano (VT)- Pitigliano (GR), 14-16 Settembre 2012, pp. 481-496
DEPALMAS AND MELIS 2010: Depalmas A., Melis A.R., 2010, The Nuragic people: their settlement, economic activities and use of land, Sardinia, Italy, in Peter Martini, I., Chesworth, W., (eds) 2010, Landscapes and Societies, Selected cases, Stuttgard, Springer, pp. 167-186.
EARLE 2016: Earle T., 2016, A Nearest-Neighbor Analysis of Two Formative Settlement Systems, in Flannery V.K. (ed.), The Early Mesoamerican Village (updated edition), Routledge, pp. 196-223
FADDA 2000: Fadda M.A. 2000, I templi a megaron della Sardegna. Un esempio particolare nel territorio di Esterzili, in Sanges M. (ed) L’eredità del Sarcidano e della Barbagia di Seulo: patrimonio di conoscenza e vita, Sassari B&P, pp. 156-158.
FADDA 2014: Fadda M.A., 2014, L’architettura dedicata al culto dell’acqua, in Moravetti A., Alba E., Foddai L. (eds), La Sardegna Nuragica. Storia e Materiali. Carlo Delfino Editore, pp. 79-92
FADDA 2017: Fadda M.A. 2017, I templi a megaron della Sardegna nuragica, in Moravetti A., Melis P.,Foddai L., Alba E. (eds.) La Sardegna Nuragica, Storia e Monumenti- Corpora delle Antichità della Sardegna, Carlo Delfino Editore, pp. 223-252.
FULMINANTE, 2016: Fulminante, F. 2016. Landscapes of Power and Prot-urban Developements towards urbanization in Bronze Age and Early Iron Age Latium vetus. 10.17863/CAM.13079.
GIETL ET AL. 2007: Gietl R., Doneus M, Fera M. 2007, Cost Distance Analysis in an Alpine Environment: Comparison of Different Cost Surface Modules, in Posluschny A., Lambers K., Herzog I (eds), Layers of Perception, Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA) 10, pp. 342-350, Berlin: Kolloquien zur Vor-und Frühgeschichte.
HAGGET 1965: Hagget P. 1965, Locational Analysis in Human Geography, Edward Arnold (Publishers) Ltd.
HARE 2004: Hare S. 2004, Using Measures of Cost Distance in the Estimation Polity Boundaries in the Postclassic Yautepec Valley, Mexico, in «Journal of Archaeological Science», 31, pp. 799-814
HARRIS 2000: Harris T., 2000, Moving GIS: Exploring movement within prehistoric cultural landscapes using GIS, in Lock G and Harris T. (eds), Beyond the Map: Archaeology and Spatial Technologies, session 2 discussion pp. 115-123, IOS Press
HIGGS AND VITA FINZI 1972: Higgs, E. S. and Vita-Finzi, C. 1972. Prehistoric Economies:A Territorial Approach. In E. S. Higgs (ed.), Papersin Economic Prehistory. Studies by Members andAssociates of the British Academy Major ResearchProject in the Early History of Agriculture, 27–36.
Cambridge, University Press.
HOWEY 2007: Howey M.C.L. 2007, Using multi-criteria cost surface analysis to explore past regional landscapes: a case study of ritual activity and social interaction in Michigan, AD 1200-1600, in «Journal of Archaeological Science» 34 (2007), pp. 1830-1846
HOLT 2015: Holt E. 2015, Mobility and Meaning in the Nuragic Culture of Bronze Age Sardinia (qwca. 1700-900 BC), in Paulina Suchowska-Ducke, Samantha Scott Reiter, Helle Vandkilde (eds), Forging Identities. The Mobility of Culture in Bronze Age Europe: Volume 1; Publisher: British Archaeological Reports
IALONGO 2011: Ialongo N., 2011, Il santuario nuragico di Monte Sant’Antonio- Siligo (SS). Studio analitico di complessi cultuali della Sardegna protostorica, Tesi di dottorato, Università La Sapienza, Roma.
IALONGO 2013: Ialongo N., 2013, Sanctuaries and the Emergence of the Elites in Nuragic Sardinia during the Early Iron Age (ca. 950-720 BC): The Actualization of a ‘Ritual Strategy’, in «Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology» 26.2 (2013), pp. 187-209
IALONGO 2017: Ialongo N., 2017, Crisis and recovery: The Cost of Sustainable Development in Nuragic Sardinia, in «European Journal of Archaeology», pp. 1-21
KNAPP 1999: Knapp B., 1999, Ideational and Industrial Landscape of Prehistoric Cyprus, in Ashmore W., Knapp B. (eds), Archaeologies of Landscape. Contemporary Perspective, Blackwell Publ., pp. 229-252
KNAPPETT 2013: Knappett C., 2013, Network Analysis in Archaeology: New Approaches to Regional Interaction, OUP Oxford.
LANGMUIR1984: Langmuir, E. 1984. Mountaincraft and leadership. The Scottish Sports Council/MLTB. Cordee, Leicester.
LILLIU 1982: Lilliu G., 1982, La civiltà Nuragica, Sassari.
LILLIU 1988: Lilliu G. 1988, La civiltà dei Sardi dal Paleolitico all’età dei nuraghi, Torino (III ed.).
LLOBERA 2000: Llobera M. 2000 Understanding movement: a pilot model towards the sociology of movement, in Lock G. (ed) Beyond the Map- Archaeology and Spatial Technologies, IOS Press, Amsterdam, pp. 65-84.
LO SCHIAVO 2014: Lo Schiavo F. 2014, La produzione metallurgica, in Moravetti A., Alba E., Foddai L. (eds), La Sardegna Nuragica. Storia e Materiali. Carlo Delfino Editore, pp. 93-120
LO SCHIAVO 2018: Lo Schiavo F. 2018, Lingotti piano-convessi (bun-ingots) ed altre forme di lingotto , in A. Giumlia-Mair and F. Lo Schiavo (eds.). MI-56. Bronze Age Metallurgy on Mediterranean Islands. Volume in honor of Robert Maddin and Vassos Karageorgis. 2018, 632 p., ill. coul. (ISBN : 978-2-35518-083-5). Collection dirigée par M. Feugère, pp. 59-136
LO SCHIAVO ET AL. 2005: Lo Schiavo F., Giumlia Mair A., Sanna U., Valera R., 2005, Archaeometallurgy in Sardinia. From the origins to the beginning of the Early Iron Age, Ed. Montagnac
LO SCHIAVO ET AL. 2009: Lo Schiavo F., Perra M., Usai A., Campus F., Leonelli V., Bernardini P., 2009, Sardegna: le ragioni dei cambiamenti nella civiltà nuragica, in «Scienze dell’Antichità, Storia Archeologia Antropologia», 15, Ed. Quasar, Roma.
MACCHI JÁNICA 2001: Macchi Jánica G. 2001, Modelli matematici per la ricostruzione dei paesaggi storici, in «Archeologia e Calcolatori» (12), pp. 143-165.
MANUNZA 2008: Manunza M.R. 2008, Funtana Coberta. Tempio nuragico a Ballao nel Gerrei, Cagliari.
MINETTI ET AL. 2002: Minetti A., Moia C. Roi G., Susta D., Ferretti G. 2002, Energy Cost of Walking and Running at Extreme Uphill and Downhill Slopes, in «Journal of Applied Physiology», 93 (3), pp. 1039-1046.
MLEKUZ 2014: Mlekuz D. 2014, "Exploring the topography of movement", in: Silvia Polla and Philip Verhagen (Eds.), Computational Approaches to the Study of Movement in Archaeology. Theory, Practice and Interpretation of Factors and Effects of Long Term Landscape Formation and Transformation, Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter, 2014, 5–22.
MUIR R. 1999: Muir R. 1999, Approaches to Landscape, MacMillan Press Ldt.
ÖSTBORN AND GERDING, 2014: Östborn, Per & Gerding, Henrik. (2014). Network Analysis of Archaeological Data: a Systematic Approach. Journal of Archaeological Science. 46. 10.1016/j.jas.2014.03.015.
PAGLIETTI 2015: Paglietti G., 2015, Dal pozzo al pozzo sacro. Riflessioni sulla cronologia del “tempio a pozzo” isodomo di Santa Vittoria di Serri, in Canu,N., Cicilloni, R., (eds) 2015, Il Santuario di Santa Vittoria di Serri, tra archeologia del passato e archeologia del futuro, Edizioni Quasar, pp. 283-292.
PAPANTONIOU AND VIONIS 2017: Papantoniou G., Vionis A.K., 2017, Landscape Archaeology and Sacred Space in the Eastern Mediterranean: A Glimpse from Cyprus, in «Land» 6 (2) 40, pp. 1-18
PAPANTONIOU AND BOUROGIANNIS 2018,: Papantoniou G., Bourogiannis G., 2018, The Cypriot Extra-Urban Sanctuary as a Central Place: The Case of Agia Irini, in «Land» (7), pp. 1-27.
PECERE 2006: Pecere B., 2006, Viewshed and Cost Surface Analyses per uno studio dei sistemi insediativi anichi: il caso della Daunia tra X e VI sec. A.C., in «Archeologia e Calcolatori» (17), 2006, pp. 177-213
PERRA 2009: Perra M., 2009, Osservazioni sull’evoluzione sociale e politica in età nuragica, in «Riviste Scienze Preistoriche», LIX, pp. 355-368.
PINARELLI 2004: Pinarelli L., 2004, Lead isotope characterization of copper ingots from Sardinia (Italy): inferences on their origins, in «Bulletin of Geological Society of Greece» vol. XXXVI, 2004, Proceedings of the 10th International Congress, Thessaloniki, April 2004, pp. 1173- 1180
RIVERS ET AL. 2011: Rivers, Ray & Knappett, C. & Evans, Tim. (2011). Network Models and Archaeological Spaces., in Bevan, M.Lake (eds), Computational Approaches to Archaeological Spaces, pp.
SALIS 2010: Salis G., 2010, Materiali di etá romana dal sito di Santa Vittoria di Esterzili: alcune considerazioni, in Milanese M., Ruggeri P., Vismara C. (eds.), L’Africa Romana, I luoghi e le forme dei mestieri e della produzione nelle province africane, Atti del XVIII Convegno di Studio, Olbia 11-14 dicembre 2008, pp. 2129-2137.
SALIS 2017: Salis G. 2017, Pozzi sacri, fonti e rotonde, Moravetti A., Melis P. , Foddai L., Alba E. (eds.) La Sardegna Nuragica, Storia e Monumenti- Corpora delle Antichità della Sardegna, Carlo Delfino Editore, pp. 253-273
SANNA 2014: Sanna V. 2014, Applicazioni GIS allo studio del paesaggio antico. Il territorio di Alghero, in Supplemento al n. 2-2014 di GEO media; XV Conferenza utenti ESRI 2014, Roma 9-10 aprile 2014, pp. 1-10.
SCHIRRU 2017: Schirru D., 2017, Nuraghi with a view: Understanding visualscape in Nuragic Marmilla (South-Central Sardinia, Italy), in «Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports» (11), pp. 106-114
STANCIC ET AL. 1995: Stancic Z., Dular J., Gaffney V., Tecco Hvala S.1995, A GIS-based analysis of Later Prehistoric settlement patterns in Dolenjska, Slovenia, in Wilcock J. and Lockyear (eds), Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (1993), BAR International Series 598, pp. 161-164, Oxford.
USAI 2003: Usai A. 2003, Sistemi insediativi e organizzazione delle comunità nuragiche nella Sardegna centro-occidentale, in Atti della XXXV Riunione Scientifica, Le comunità della preistoria italiana, Studi e ricerche sul neolitico e l’età dei metalli, (Castello Lipari, Chiesa di Santa Caterina, 2-7 giugno 2000) (Estratto), Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, Firenze, pp. 216-224.
USAI 2006: Usai A., 2006, Osservazioni sul popolamento e sulle forme di organizzazione comunitaria nella Sardegna nuragica, in Studi di Protostoria in onore di Renato Peroni, All’Insegna del Giglio Ed., pp. 557-566
USAI 2009: Usai A. 2009, Cenni sul Montiferru e la Planargia meridionale in Età nuragica, in Pes P., Usai A. e Cossu T.(eds) Archeologia tra Planargia e Montiferru, Cagliari, pp. 263-296.
USAI 2015: Usai A. 2015, Paesaggi nuragici, in Minoja M., Salis G., Usai L. (edited by), L’Isola delle torri. Giovanni Lilliu e la Sardegna Nuragica, Sassari, pp. 58-69.
VALERA ET AL. 2005: Valera R.G., Valera P.G., Rivoldini A., 2005, Sardinian ore deposits and metals in the Bronze Age, in Lo Schiavo F., Giumlia Mair A., Sanna U., Valera R. (eds), Archaeometallurgy in Sardinia. From the origins to the beginning of the Early Iron Age, Ed. Montagnac, pp. 43-88
VAN LEUSEN 1998: Van Leusen P.M.V. 1998, Viewshed and Cost Surface Analysis Using GIS (Cartographic Modelling in a Cell-Based GIS II), in: Barceló, J.A., I. Briz and A. Vila (eds.) New Techniques for Old Times. CAA98. Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology. Proceedings of the 26th Conference, Barcelona, March 1998 (BAR International Series 757). Archaeopress, Oxford, pp. 215-224.
VAN LEUSEN 2002 : Van Leusen P.M.V. 2002, Pattern to process methodological investigations into the formation and interpretation of spatial patterns in archaeological landscapes, (Doctoral thesis), Rijksuniversiteit Groningen. Universiteitsbibliotheek.
VANZETTI ET AL. 2013: Vanzetti A., Castangia G., Depalmas A., Ialongo N., Leonelli V., Perra M., Usai A. 2013, Complessi fortificati della Sardegna e delle isole del Mediterraneo Occidentale nella Protostoria, in Bartoloni G., Michetti L.M. (edited by) Mura di legno, mura di terra, mura di pietra: fortificazioni del Mediterraneo antico, Atti del Convegno Internazionale, Sapienza Università di Roma, 7-9 maggio 2012, Edizioni Quasar, pp. 83-123.
WEBSTER 2015: Webster G., 2015, The Archaeology of Nuragic Sardinia, Equinox Publisher
WHEATLEY AND GILLINGS 2002: Wheatley D., Gillings M. 2002, Archaeology, space and GIS, in Spatial Technology and Archaeology, Taylor & Francis, New York, pp. 1-18
Copyright (c) 2020 Valentina Matta
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
